Bologna Environmental Economics Group (BEEG) Seminar
5 November 2026
Seminar with Massimiliano Mazzanti and Francesco Giovanardi
- 12:30 PM - 02:00 PM
- Online on Microsoft Teams and in person : Seminar Room, Piazza Scaravilli 2, Bologna
- Science & Technology, Society & Culture In English
How to partecipate
Free admission subject to availability
Program
Seminar 1
Speaker: Massimiliano Mazzanti
Title: Assessing the effect of carbon pricing (EU ETS) and R&D investments in a panel setting: A Functional principal component analysis
Abstract: The European Emission trading system (EU ETS) is currently the World’s largest carbon market. After 20 decades of development since the starting of the pilot phase back in 2005, it is under reform, towards a new phase. Price stability and the use of Auction revenues to support investments are key issues under scrutiny, recalling that 25 years ago the European emission trading was launched due to a lack of political support for the ecological tax reforms, which the European Commission Delors report proposed in the early 90’s. The extent to which this environmental policy, based on a (regulated) financial system, delivers environmental, innovation and economic performances is more and more relevant as the ecological transition moves on. In a Multiple transition setting, as environmental policy stringency does increase (emission trading ‘caps’ decrease), the socio-economic incremental costs might enlarge. Cost benefit analyses are more and more necessary, through diversified methodologies within macroeconomic and microeconomic settings. It is pretty normal that in front of geo political turmoil, energy crisis, increasing CO2 prices that reflect marginal abatement costs, the debate on competitiveness vs environmental sustainability is now hotter than in the past. As a complement to a consolidated microeconomic literature focusing on firms performances as driven by ETS (firms covered and not covered), this macroeconomic panel data oriented paper covering the entire economic system (ETS and non ETS sectors) provides a new functional analysis that exploits carbon pricing weekly data to capture the intrinsic non linearity of the financial system and consequently the effect of CO2 prices and variance on the key target: TOTAL CO2 emissions in the EU (not only ETS emissions, decreasing by definition).
It is worth noting that an high degree of uncertainty surrounds the shape (and sign) of the environmental policy effect. There are no ex-ante theoretical or empirical reasons to impose a specific parametric relation between CO2 and the price of carbon. The big issue is always: Which is the true Data Generating Process? In general, the Standard approach is assuming the DGP, represented by parametric models and then estimate the model (robustness checks then follow). We recognise model uncertainty by relying on Nonparametric regression and model selection. Thus, as a complement to a consolidated microeconomic literature focusing on firms (Borghesi et al. 2015ab), this macroeconomic panel data-oriented paper provides a new functional analysis that exploits carbon pricing weekly data to capture the intrinsic nonlinearity of the financial system and consequently the effect of CO2 prices and variance on the key target: CO2 emissions in the EU.
Building upon recent papers on carbon pricing effects in panel setting using parametric and non-parametric models, and the development of statistical models that may add insights compared to more standard econometric modelling (Cardot and Musolesi, 2025; Soberon et al., 2025; Musolesi et al. 2025), this paper scrutinises the relationship between carbon pricing and emissions in a panel dataset (2005-2023) through models that exploit weekly data variability in CO2 prices. As far as estimation and Inference are concerned, model parameters (including the functional effect) are estimated jointly using least squares on the expanded model; uncertainty for the functional component is quantified via bootstrap confidence intervals based on inflated residuals.
The main result is that the overall effect of carbon pricing is not significant over a long period of time, till the 2020 turning point. After that, due to energy issues and policy expectations that increased prices during a pandemic recession, the effect of prices on emissions does appear to be significant. During a phase of strong variability but consolidated high prices (namely 2020-2023, where prices reached 100€ per tonne and then stabilised around 70-75€), compared to the historical average, the EU ETS delivered its market-based policy signal to emissions. As the figure below shows, the effect of carbon pricing on emissions is significant after the 2020 turning point. Over the pandemic crisis, possibly driven by strong policy expectations, EU ETS prices rose. The empirical evidence is in line with other recent papers (Soberon et al. 2025) that showed that, notwithstanding strong historical non linearities, carbon pricing exerted significant reductions in emissions in a macroeconomic setting. The most recent and mature phase of EU ETS pricing development kicked emissions down. The present paper, using different methods and weekly data, additionally shows that in the very recent history of EU ETS prices were a significant driver of decarbonisation (see Fig.1 below presenting the effects of GDP, R&D (GERD) and Carbon pricing on European emissions under a non parametric environmental Kuznets curves modelling framework).
Seminar 2
Speaker: Francesco Giovanardi
Co-Author: F. Diluiso, M. Kaldorf
Title: Optimal Sustainability-Linked Collateral Policy
Abstract: We study the interactions of central bank collateral policy and emission taxes in a DSGE model with energy production and financial frictions in both the firm and banking sectors. A Sustainability-Linked Collateral Policy (SLCP), under which energy debt receives larger haircuts when energy production is more carbon-intensive, incentivizes clean technology adoption within the energy sector - the emission mitigation channel - and insulates the central bank from climate policy transition risk - the central bank exposure channel. Such a policy is optimal if the emission tax level is low or the emission tax volatility is high. Different from prior literature, the welfare gains through the emission mitigation channel largely stem from technology adoption within the energy sector rather than a shift towards less emission-intensive sectors. However, the SLCP implies low energy sector haircuts if emission taxes are temporarily high, such that energy firms switch to clean technologies and are closer to default. To reduce central bank exposure in these states, we propose a climate policy cycle adjustment to the SLCP, which ensures that energy sector haircuts rise if emission taxes are temporarily high.
Speakers
-
Massimiliano Mazzanti
Full Professor
University of Ferrara -
Francesco Giovanardi
Research Specialist
Prometeia